Award YearWinner?Award CategoryTitleAuthor's NamePublisher/ProducerNotes
2014 x Best Novel Ordinary Grace William Kent Krueger Simon & Schuster/Atria Books
2014 Best Novel How the Light Gets In Louise Penny Minotaur Books
2014 Best Novel Sandrine's Case Thomas H. Cook Grove Atlantic - The Mysterious Press
2014 Best Novel Standing in Another Man's Grave Ian Rankin Hachette Book Group/Reagan Arthur Books
2014 Best Novel The Humans Matt Haig Simon & Schuster
2014 Best Novel Until She Comes Home Lori Roy Penguin Group USA - Dutton
2014 x Best First Novel Red Sparrow Jason Matthews Simon & Schuster/Scribner
2014 Best First Novel Ghostman Roger Hobbs Alfred A. Knopf
2014 Best First Novel Rage Against the Dying Becky Masterman Minotaur Books
2014 Best First Novel Reconstructing Amelia Kimberly McCreight HarperCollins Publishers - Harper
2014 Best First Novel The Resurrectionist Matthew Guinn W.W. Norton & Co.
2014 x Best Paperback Original The Wicked Girls Alex Marwood Penguin Group USA - Penguin Books
2014 Best Paperback Original Almost Criminal E.R. Brown Dundurn Group
2014 Best Paperback Original Brilliance Marcus Sakey Amazon Publishing - Thomas and Mercer
2014 Best Paperback Original Joe Victim Paul Cleave Simon & Schuster/Atria Books
2014 Best Paperback Original Joyland Stephen King Hard Case Crime
2014 Best Paperback Original The Guilty One Lisa Ballantyne HarperCollins - William Morrow Paperbacks
2014 x Best Short Story The Caxton Private Lending Library and Book Depository John Connolly Mysterious Bookshop Volume: Bibliomysteries
2014 Best Short Story So Long, Chief Max Allan Collins, Mickey Spillane The Strand
2014 Best Short Story The Terminal Reed Farrel Coleman Amazon Publishing - Thomas and Mercer Anthology: Kwik Krimes
2014 Best Short Story There are Roads in the Water Trina Corey Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine Volume: January 2013
2014 Best Short Story Where That Morning Sun Goes Down Tim L. Williams Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine Volume: August 2013
2014 x Best Fact Crime The Hour of Peril: The Secret Plot to Murder Lincoln Before the Civil War Daniel Stashower Minotaur Books
2014 Best Fact Crime Duel with the Devil: The True Story of how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr Teamed Up to Take on America's First Sensational Murder Mystery Paul Collins Crown Publishers
2014 Best Fact Crime Mortal Sins: Sex, Crime, and the Era of Catholic Scandal Michael D'Antonio Thomas Dunne Books